Forum rules
Please always provide all needed information to identify your problems. Screenshots and detailed descriptions makes it easier for us to help
Neuling
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri 3. Aug 2018, 09:02

Running effectiveness

Hi!

Was wondering what types of values people are seeing for running effectiveness? Reading some of the literature it seems like 1.0 is a 'good value', I seem to be averaging .7 or so at the moment and I'm just wondering what types of values others are seeing, particularly recreational runners vs more serious folks.

Thanks!
0 x

matsalo
Runalyzer
Posts: 51
Joined: Mon 4. Jun 2018, 11:30

Re: Running effectiveness

Is running effectiveness depending that the recording device you are using also record some value for force/effect and store it in the session file you import, or can runalyze calculate the necessary values itself? I haven't values for anything related to effect in my database; I just get empty fields for e.g running effectiveness if I try to show these fields.
0 x

laufhannes
Core developer
Posts: 479
Joined: Mon 29. Jul 2013, 20:59

Re: Running effectiveness

Running effectiveness is a simple metric setting speed and power in relation: RE [kg/N] = Speed [m/s] / Power [W/kg].

See https://runalyze.com/glossary/running-effectiveness

As I don't have a device that records (/estimates) power while running, I don't know how valuable the standard values defined by Palladino are (i.e. values between 0.99 and 1.01 as average).
0 x

matsalo
Runalyzer
Posts: 51
Joined: Mon 4. Jun 2018, 11:30

Re: Running effectiveness

I understood the metric, but wondered about the power variable. Under sport settings I can choose to tick of "Power", and the explanation given is that power is either recorded or calculated. My impression is that without a recorded power (or more correct as you state a device that estimate power), all metrics and calculation with relation to power gives no results. I have neither a device that record power, and hasn't tested anything else.

Therefor I wondered since the explanation says is either calculated if not recorded.
0 x

elske
Runalyzer
Posts: 33
Joined: Tue 6. Sep 2016, 17:32

Re: Running effectiveness

I'm using the Garmin data field for power estimation and I usually get something around 0.65. I'm somewhat serious, my 5k PR is about 20min for reference.
0 x

JoGu
Runalyzer
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon 7. Jul 2014, 08:59

Re: Running effectiveness

Palladino seems somewhat connected to Stryd. Their values are somewhat higher than the values you are getting from the Garmin-calculations.
The Problem with all these Running-Powermeters is that there simply is no defined standard. That is also the reason why you do not see Power as a Standard-Field on Garmin watches.
Every company can calculate the values as they like (or as their specific tests tell them to).
As long as they all do not consent on the same standard there is no way in using these metrics to compare different Companies/Products.

Regards,
Jörg
0 x